Skip to content

Abu Qatada and the Balance We Must Strike

On a module I convene – Terrorism and Insurgencies – I have been discussing Islamic radicalisation. The timing could not be more apt.  As well as the issues and debates surrounding the use of evidence obtained under torture, the release of Abu Qatada  signifies a fundamental problem that not only the UK but many other liberal democracies face when it comes to threats against the state. How do we strike a balance between the effectiveness of the implementation of  laws and on their acceptability not just to the law abiding majority but also the accused minority.

We should remember that Abu Qatada has not been charged with a crime within the UK’s judicial system and yet he will be subjected to some of the harshest restrictions imposed on any UK resident (both in and out of jail) since 9/11. There is no doubting that he is not only a “truly dangerous individual” but also “a key figure” in Islamist terrorist activity. Having him behind bars would be a benefit to us all. Liberal democracies, however, are disadvantaged in the struggle against terrorism, as respecting the rights of the minority invariably means the application of measured, rule based force. As the late Paul Wilkinson put it: “by tolerating the intolerant, democracies allow terrorists to plan and prepare their strikes [whereas] by definition totalitarian regimes suppress all effective opposition within their boundaries and are entirely unimpeded by any judicial or humanitarian constraints”.

The preservation of values such as equality, freedom, justice and tolerance are not ones that totalitarian-authoritarian regimes subscribe to. As such they are able to employ harsh, unyielding forms of oppression and retribution to counter terrorist related activity; but more importantly, and relevantly, they are able to simply lock-up suspects without charge. We, in the UK tried a similar measure in Northern Ireland, under the policy of Internment. The 1971 British Army initiative undoubtedly served as recruiting sergeant; giving reason and rationale to ever greater numbers wishing to join the Provisional IRA.

Liberal democratic states have historically found themselves having to strike a balance between acceptability and effectiveness; with states asking ‘do we want to sacrifice some democratic substance in order to be effective against terrorism or do we have to tolerate a certain level of terrorism for the sake of maintaining the civil liberties and political rights which we cherish?’

An example of this dilemma can be seen in the October 2005 debate in the UK regarding the proposed extension of the period in which the police can detain, without charge, people suspected of involvement with terrorism. One of the matters considered was whether the state should introduce one law for the majority (non-terrorists) and another for the minority (suspected terrorists), who may be suspected of committing terrorist acts. It may be argued that by defending the proposed extension, the UK Government enhanced perceptions of its inability to govern within the established laws of the state. That being the case, it may also be argued that the lack of formal charges and the use of harsh unyielding curfew restrictions serves as further evidence of liberal democracy’s inability to curtail what is at heart another form of criminal activity – terrorism.

Edgar Tembo

Published inBritish PoliticsInternational PoliticsTerrorismThe Far-Right & Extremism

10 Comments

  1. Hmm it appears like your website ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to everything. Do you have any tips for first-time blog writers? I’d definitely appreciate it.

  2. What’s up colleagues, how is all, and what you would like to say about this article, in my
    view its in fact awesome in support of me.

  3. My feet are extremely dry and hard. Within a day you’ll feel a difference, it’s keep the heels soft
    and moist

  4. As ibexpensive as they are, people ten to procrastinate on changing their windshield wipers.

    This is the ennd off generic phonebook listings and the
    launch of a unique website; This site bdes to be the future
    of online auto repair research. To tell the facts, it can be a groundbreaking
    creation.

  5. You can also refer to our color tab for the entire selection of Viro Fiber,
    Rehau Fiber and Sunbrella Choices. Modern security control rooms employ custom ergonomic designed furniture that
    meets the needs of individual operators. According to your
    home and choice, you can buy any type of furniture and make your home beautiful and attractive.

  6. By now all of us a acquainted with Bakugan battle brawler
    games and its anime series. She ain’t no ballerina,
    but “B-girl Terra” can sure bust a move. Complete Fight Night Champion roaster list here shows you all
    of the roasters in the game.

  7. If you wish for to obtain much from this post then you have to apply these techniques to your won website.

  8. Make sure that the slats are close enough together
    so that your childs head cannot become trapped between them.
    That iss why parents have roles tto take and teach their kids or send them to a driving school
    to knokw how to maneuver a ccar properly.
    Child experts and even OB Gynecologists will tell the expectant couple to prepare a few things a month or
    so before the projected birth date.

  9. Nice to see your post, dude! Thankyou so much for your work!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *